There is fine line between wry, sarcastic humor and plain old racial slur. And many times, writers writing in tongue-in-cheek fashion cross the line either knowingly or unknowingly.
Case in point: An article recently appeared in a Hongkong online magazine that slammed Filipinos for claiming ownership of the Spratly Islands. This was written by Chip Tsao, a Hongkong-based columnist and broadcaster. Here is his "The War at Home" article from his column published March 27, 2009:
March 27th, 2009The Russians sank a Hong Kong freighter last month, killing the seven Chinese seamen on board. We can live with that—Lenin and Stalin were once the ideological mentors of all Chinese people. The Japanese planted a flag on Diàoyú Island. That’s no big problem—we Hong Kong Chinese love Japanese cartoons, Hello Kitty, and shopping in Shinjuku, let alone our round-the-clock obsession with karaoke.
But hold on—even the Filipinos? Manila has just claimed sovereignty over the scattered rocks in the South China Sea called the Spratly Islands, complete with a blatant threat from its congress to send gunboats to the South China Sea to defend the islands from China if necessary. This is beyond reproach. The reason: there are more than 130,000 Filipina maids working as $3,580-a-month cheap labor in Hong Kong. As a nation of servants, you don’t flex your muscles at your master, from whom you earn most of your bread and butter.
As a patriotic Chinese man, the news has made my blood boil. I summoned Louisa, my domestic assistant who holds a degree in international politics from the University of Manila, hung a map on the wall, and gave her a harsh lecture. I sternly warned her that if she wants her wages increased next year, she had better tell every one of her compatriots in Statue Square on Sunday that the entirety of the Spratly Islands belongs to China.
Grimly, I told her that if war breaks out between the Philippines and China, I would have to end her employment and send her straight home, because I would not risk the crime of treason for sponsoring an enemy of the state by paying her to wash my toilet and clean my windows 16 hours a day. With that money, she would pay taxes to her government, and they would fund a navy to invade our motherland and deeply hurt my feelings.
Oh yes. The government of the Philippines would certainly be wrong if they think we Chinese are prepared to swallow their insult and sit back and lose a Falkland Islands War in the Far East. They may have Barack Obama and the hawkish American military behind them, but we have a hostage in each of our homes in the Mid-Levels or higher. Some of my friends told me they have already declared a state of emergency at home. Their maids have been made to shout “China, Madam/Sir” loudly whenever they hear the word “Spratly.” They say the indoctrination is working as wonderfully as when we used to shout, “Long live Chairman Mao!” at the sight of a portrait of our Great Leader during the Cultural Revolution. I’m not sure if that’s going a bit too far, at least for the time being.
Chip Tsao is a best-selling author and columnist. A former reporter for the BBC, his columns have also appeared in Apple Daily, Next Magazine and CUP Magazine, among others.
In the interest of fairness, I want to put the article and the writer in perspective. I did a quick Google search on Chip Tsao and found that he is really known for his irreverent humor. His column is named Politically Incorrect after all, so the readers are already being forewarned that it is not for the thin-skinned and faint-hearted. This is not the first time that his article sparked controversy. Back in 2005, he found himself in a quagmire after writing about interracial dating in Hongkong. It was not the first time either that he wrote about Filipinos, he featured an article about Filipino wet nurses as an alternative source of milk in Hongkong when the melamine milk scare broke out last year.
But hard as I try to be more tolerant and understanding of his writing style, I cannot help but feel that his article has struck a sensitive chord among us Filipinos. I guess unknowingly, he went overboard with this one. My reaction to his article was not anger at all, it was sadness. I felt I was Louisa, being looked down to, being discriminated against, and haplessly allowing my employer to take advantage of the dire economic situation I am in. Reading the article was like being taken back to the few times when I have been at the receiving end of discrimination during trips abroad.
Moreover, the Philippine government is not the Filipino people. I have long hoped and waited in vain for our incumbent president to relinquish her post, and many share this same sentiment. I sure do regret ever voting for Glora Arroyo, that was a big faux pas on my part. There are many things that this government did that I am not very proud of and I understand the negative image we may have among other nations. But just because there are a few bad apples, it does not make the entire bunch bad. There are a lot of good apples out there, Louisa, whether she is fictional or not, is one of them.
I will not stoop down to Chip Tsao's level by lashing out on the Hongkong Chinese. I will not even judge Chip Tsao’s character too. One or two articles gone wrong do not make him a bad writer nor a bad person for that matter. I would give him the benefit of the doubt and would charge all these to simple poor judgment on his part. I hope this article does not unmake him, but his fate does not rely on my hands. Too many Filipinos are outraged by what he has said.
I am magnanimous in my forgiveness. I hope this speaks of the character a Filipino can have.